Sunday, February 13, 2011
COMPARING WORLD EDUCATION
I think it worth posting this ranking of reading ability by nationality. The UK at 494 isn't abysmal, indeed we are just above the average but being ahead of Hungary and Portugal and behind the Poles is hardly a source of pride or confidence. Scotland's comes in at a marginally better 500 but there is a clear downward trend since 526 in 2000.
Don't expect this to be as widely discussed by politicians and media as the pulchitrudity or otherwise of party leader's partners.
This is Pournelle on the US system, which he considers dreadful though it comes out a lot better than ours.
The purpose of the US education system is to insure employment of bad teachers. It is well known that the efficiency of the system as measured by student performance will be about doubled by firing the 10% worst teachers and apportioning their students out among the rest; that is overwhelmingly to be preferred to "smaller classroom size", teacher pay raises, or anything else that might be tried. Of course this won't be tried because the purpose of the whole system is to see to it that the bad teachers are not fired and are allowed to go through ruining lives until they get large pensions.
The second purpose of the system is to insure full employment for professors of education, many of whom have never done any actual teaching, but whose imprimatur is needed to get the "merit pay" advances you can get from "workshops" and various courses in education. Some education colleges actually prepare teachers to teach, but many simply punch tickets; a lot of bad teachers who ought to be fired get "merit" pay for having accumulated credits from education professors. My suspicion is that firing about half the professors of education would greatly improve the efficiency of the system but I don't have any studies or numbers to prove that; but I would bet money that firing the worst 10% would instantly improve the colleges of education just as firing the worst 10% of classroom teachers would instantly improve the schools.
The purpose of the schools is to extract money from taxpayers and pay it in ways that insure that professors of education and bad teachers get paid. It is not to create citizens, or to teach anything; it is not to train future Legionnaires. If we are to have Legions, the first thing we need to do is cut all ties between the Armed Forces school systems for service dependents from the rest of the education system and run it in a rational manner as it has been done in the past. Alas the trend is in the other direction, with more and more of the poison that ruined the US public school system spreading everywhere else.
Schools no longer prepare students to be citizens or to learn the skills to be employed, even in the Legions. They have new purposes now, and they serve them well.
Labels: British politics, Fixing the economy, Social
Comments:
<< Home
I want to point out that many of the countries in the commonwealth do better than the UK. Canada (524) and New Zealand (521) both score better than their mother country (494). Considering the racial differences in ability that show up in the US I wouldn't be surprised if the scores of Britain's native White population was higher than its South Asian/Pakistani population.
The second point I want to make is that once we acknowledge racial differences in ability we see massive differences in outcome even adjusted for IQ. A good example of this underachievement would be Argentina, which according to IQ and the Wealth of Nations has a median IQ of 96, but has an educational achievement level lower than US Blacks (85).
I don't have a clue right now how to scatter plot the educational data versus IQ, but I would bet that there would be a lot of countries above and below the correlation line. Pournelle's lament about the US educational system is probably much more true in the third world than it is in America or Britain.
The second point I want to make is that once we acknowledge racial differences in ability we see massive differences in outcome even adjusted for IQ. A good example of this underachievement would be Argentina, which according to IQ and the Wealth of Nations has a median IQ of 96, but has an educational achievement level lower than US Blacks (85).
I don't have a clue right now how to scatter plot the educational data versus IQ, but I would bet that there would be a lot of countries above and below the correlation line. Pournelle's lament about the US educational system is probably much more true in the third world than it is in America or Britain.
# posted by 
: February 19, 2011
: February 19, 2011
These Ciommonwealth countries are also richer than us, including Singapore & it is not unreasonable to expect richer countries to afford a better educational system.
Britain does have a significant oriental population, which should push up IQ. It is smaller than the Pakistani one & far less noisy.
Britain does have a significant oriental population, which should push up IQ. It is smaller than the Pakistani one & far less noisy.
I chose Argentina because there could be cultural and bureaucratic factors holding a country back. Let me give you an extreme example close to your heart: Serbia. If you look at the graph you posted you will notice that Serbian educational achievement is on par with US Blacks, and yet having met a few they did not strike me as stupid. Russia is also a major underachiever, and the sink estates of Scotland that you mentioned could be directing young boys away from school causing Scotland's score to be lower than Scottish IQ would dictate.
# posted by : February 19, 2011
: February 19, 2011
yes but the correlation with national wealth is very strong I am interested in ones that break that mold eg Shanghai at the top & very wealthy Dubai at 459 & even then Shanghai is not poor & Dubai is only a generation out of the desert. The Israeli one is difficult to explain, as is its low IQ score generally particularly when experience indicates otherwise.
Israel is a multiethnic society whose population is one-fifth Arab. Since the Arabs most likely have a median IQ of 85, this depresses Israel's country average. Furthermore, the Jewish population is divided into groups of differing ability, with these groups having median IQ's of 70 (Ethiopian Jews) to 110+ (Pure blooded Ashkenazi).
Having said all that though, I think Israel makes really good use of its talent regardless of how smart its population is.
Having said all that though, I think Israel makes really good use of its talent regardless of how smart its population is.
# posted by : February 19, 2011
: February 19, 2011
Israel's success may be confirmation of Heinlein's position that what matters is the very small number at the far end of the normal curve (1%, 0.1%?)
It is a good factor to check the many countries education system by which each and every country can follow the opposite country education system to urge the higher system for their students that is extremely useful for them and for their education that is extremely good for them to implement on the students assignment help service.
Ireland assignment help provides the best quality assignment help ireland
services to the students. Our professional writers can write any assignment as they are well-versed with every assignment topic.
services to the students. Our professional writers can write any assignment as they are well-versed with every assignment topic.
# posted by : April 11, 2018
: April 11, 2018
This kind of world education chart is necessary to know about which country more educate than other one. Previously we don't have internet and other things best CV writing service UK to know about achievement and development from other countries but its easy now.
This article is quite useful for individuals to need to know little Asian nations like Singapore have scored up their education method and has seen positive changes Help with Essay.
Whilst readers may additionally find Baca's poetry greater outstanding than this prose memoir about how he had become a poet, the author still manages to seize both the reader's interest and sympathies. Baca traverses his lifestyles, beginning with his adolescence in rural new mexico—wherein both dad and mom basically deserted him—his formative years in "Juvee" halls and his days as a drug supplier. The story leads up to an account of five years in a most-security prison in Arizona, and the unusual non-public transformation that occurs there thru his gaining knowledge of to read and write; sooner or later, he discovers his poetic voice.
Best Regards
Do my Essay | 6$ Essay.
Best Regards
Do my Essay | 6$ Essay.
The text is established like a conversion narrative in which Baca's past symbolizes all that is bad and his poetry-orientated future is packed with the hope and optimism that come from coming across something divine inside the midst of darkness. He also recounts the intricacies of jail politics, wherein failure to gain admire and alliances cast with the wrong people can imply demise. Oddly, certain tale strains are truly dropped alongside the manner, such as his rate that the prison turned into lacing his meals with robust psychoactive pills | Source by Homework Writing Services.
Finland is a pinnacle of the sector for happiness, in step with the world happiness record 2018, intently followed by using Norway, Denmark, Iceland, Switzerland, and the Netherlands. Nordic countries take 4 out of the five pinnacle spots and are widely recognized to be strong, secure and socially progressive | Write My Homework - Daily Homework Help.
The blog post is really pleasing because it talks about A Place to Stand. The article compares world education. The countries around the world used to have different educational systems and approaches. Knowing these different educational approaches will help you to understand the unanimity of your country’s education. The graph given in the article will help you to understand what they are intending from the article.
Thanks,
Henry E. Mathews
Essays writing service
Thanks,
Henry E. Mathews
Essays writing service
# posted by : November 03, 2018
: November 03, 2018
It is very interesting to read regarding world education status. From, this detailed analysis; we can understand the position of every country in the field of education. We can also come to know about the resources available in all the countries. This survey gives us the idea that how much every country is spending money on education resources. It provides us with the prediction that for future that where will be chances more for higher and quality education. Every country is coming up with own ideas and syllabus to improve their education quality. I am a writer and I always read new changes in the field of education. I help students with their writing projects. I provide them with Cheap essay USA . this is helpful for them to understand about the new writing methods.
# posted by : February 12, 2019
: February 12, 2019
www.lampungservice.com
https://servicecentermito.blogspot.com/
https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/pt-lampung-service
https://youtubelampung.blogspot.com/
https://konsultanhp.wordpress.com/
https://komunitasyoutuberindonesia.wordpress.com
https://youtuberandroid.wordpress.com
https://youtuberterbaikindonesia.wordpress.com
https://servicecentermito.blogspot.com/
https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/pt-lampung-service
https://youtubelampung.blogspot.com/
https://konsultanhp.wordpress.com/
https://komunitasyoutuberindonesia.wordpress.com
https://youtuberandroid.wordpress.com
https://youtuberterbaikindonesia.wordpress.com
# posted by : April 11, 2019
: April 11, 2019
Today students need to juggle up assignments, tests, social life and family time altogether. It has turned out extremely tough to get so much handled with perfection. Since college professors tend to establish high demands for their classes, with a belief that students can easily cope with all those requirements. However, students for coming up with the entire home assignment, need to either sacrifice their leisure time for studying harder or finish the work recklessly.
assignment writing services UK
assignment writing services UK
# posted by : May 21, 2019
: May 21, 2019
Hey all, here is the detailed informative page about Sarkari Result Exams, a website which is well known for its genuine information about government jobs.
Checkout each and every detail you want to inquire about the website.
Thanks.
Checkout each and every detail you want to inquire about the website.
Thanks.
Thanks for sharing this informative post. When anyone gets something new or useful information at the start of their day, that people make happy by reading some helpful information. I think we can get a moral lesson from this post. Because this post has a lot of knowledge about education. Get help from dissertation proposal writing services a distinctive writing company UK
Airline Reservation System is the best way to make your travel more popular among the travelers. Team India Web design offers the error-free Airline Reservation System and Airline API integration system to the travel agents at the best price.
https://www.teamindiawebdesign.com/airline-reservation-system
https://www.teamindiawebdesign.com/airline-reservation-system
After looking at a number of the blog articles on your web page, I honestly like your technique of blogging. I book-marked it to my bookmark website list and will be checking back soon. Take a look at my web site too and tell me how you feel.
premium dissertation uk
premium dissertation uk
An intriguing discussion is worth comment. I do think that you need to publish more on this subject matter, it may not be a taboo matter but generally folks don't speak about these issues. To the next! Best wishes!!
tnmachi
tnmachi
This is a topic which is near to my heart... Take care! Exactly where are your contact details though?movieswood
Good post. I learn something new and challenging on websites I stumbleupon on a daily basis. It will always be interesting to read content from other authors and use something from their sites.kissanime
Aw, this was an extremely nice post. Taking a few minutes and actual effort to make a good article… but what can I say… I put things off a whole lot and never manage to get anything done.mastihot
An interesting discussion is worth comment. There's no doubt that that you ought to publish more about this subject matter, it may not be a taboo matter but typically people don't speak about these issues. To the next! Kind regards!.Best Plasma Cutter
You made some good points there. I looked on the internet for additional information about the issue and found most individuals will go along with your views on this website.
Cheap Plasama Cutter
Cheap Plasama Cutter
Spot on with this write-up, I seriously believe that this amazing site needs much more attention. I’ll probably be back again to read through more, thanks for the information!.
Best Plasma Cutter Under 300
Best Plasma Cutter Under 300
Every student needs someone who can help them in assignment, dissertation, coursework, essays or many more like these all. We are here to help you in all these. Our team is specialist in assignment writing service and also in coursework help. We give this service from the native of UK
Educational systems around the world have many differences, though the same factors—including resources and money—affect every educational system.
We need to consider many things before comparing. I got essay writing on the same topic from my college and Unifolks helped me out in that, they provide a well-written essay with detailed and valid points and headings.
We need to consider many things before comparing. I got essay writing on the same topic from my college and Unifolks helped me out in that, they provide a well-written essay with detailed and valid points and headings.
Comparing education systems across the world can be a complex task, as there are many factors to consider, including the cultural and economic context of each country. However, some common metrics are often used to make such comparisons, including literacy rates, enrollment rates, graduation rates, and international test scores.
One of the most commonly used international tests to compare education systems is the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA), which assesses the reading, mathematics, and science literacy of 15-year-old students from participating countries. The results of the PISA test have shown that countries such as Finland, South Korea, Japan, and Singapore consistently rank highly in terms of student performance, while other countries, such as the United States, the United Kingdom, and Australia, often lag behind.
In addition to test scores, other factors that are often considered when comparing education systems include access to education, teacher quality, curriculum standards, and educational resources. For example, countries with higher levels of investment in education best lsat prep courses, such as Sweden and Norway, often have higher levels of teacher pay, smaller class sizes, and better access to educational resources.
Overall, comparing education systems across the world is a complex task, and it is important to consider the various factors that contribute to the quality of education in each country. Nevertheless, by examining various metrics such as test scores, enrollment rates, and graduation rates, it is possible to gain some insights into how different education systems compare.
Post a Comment
One of the most commonly used international tests to compare education systems is the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA), which assesses the reading, mathematics, and science literacy of 15-year-old students from participating countries. The results of the PISA test have shown that countries such as Finland, South Korea, Japan, and Singapore consistently rank highly in terms of student performance, while other countries, such as the United States, the United Kingdom, and Australia, often lag behind.
In addition to test scores, other factors that are often considered when comparing education systems include access to education, teacher quality, curriculum standards, and educational resources. For example, countries with higher levels of investment in education best lsat prep courses, such as Sweden and Norway, often have higher levels of teacher pay, smaller class sizes, and better access to educational resources.
Overall, comparing education systems across the world is a complex task, and it is important to consider the various factors that contribute to the quality of education in each country. Nevertheless, by examining various metrics such as test scores, enrollment rates, and graduation rates, it is possible to gain some insights into how different education systems compare.
<< Home
