![Click to get your own widget Click to get your own widget](http://cache4.intelliweather.net/wcw/world_climate_widget_sidebar.gif)
Wednesday, November 07, 2007
"this paper could not be more damaging to manmade global warming theory"
UPDATE & SPOILER WARNING I put up the undernoted article last night. As the numerous comments have pointed out it is a hoax. Indeed according to desmoblog:
"Hat's off (we think) to UK writer and consultant David Thorpe, the apparent creator for the impressive web-based spoof - a definitive bit of climate change denial as reported in The Journal of Geoclimatic Studies.
Although the "journal" lists two volumes and some very tempting content*, the only research paper on the website is titled: "Carbon dioxide production by benthic bacteria: the death of manmade global warming theory?" The paper reports that rising volumes of CO2 are actually caused "by saprotrophic eubacteria living in the sediments of the continental shelves fringing the Atlantic and Pacific oceans."
Unfortunately, this wonderful news is attributed to a group of scientists who can't be found, working at a series of institutions or departments that don't exist."
Well Mr Thorpe I think the chance of this being mentioned by the BBC has just increased massively - they haven't reported the fact of 1998 being found no longer to be the warmest year on record, but would not be surprised to find them willing to report a hoax. There was a similar incident when "environmentalists" sent a signature to the 17,000 strong Oregon Petition of scientists denying catastrophic warming, in the name of Dr Geri Halliwell. Elsewhere I said that all that that proved is that the Oregon scientists weren't followers of the Spice Girls & that warming alarmists had no compunctions about fakery - neither of which reflect worse on the victims of the hoax than the perpetrators.
This is a much more subtle hoax but the point still stands. The speed of the reaction to their successful hoax is interesting. I would hope that more responsible alarmists, if that is not a contradiction in terms, will advise Mr Thorpe, assuming he is indeed the author, that this is not how science is done.
On the other hand they didn't object to the hoaxed "facts" in Mr Gore's film, which he may be about to assure us were also deliberate :-)
FURTHER UPDATE
Pete North has sent me the undernoted links from Australia.
"You were quite right about the hoax study now going to be all over the news worldwide- since it is obviously trying to make ALL of the GW sceptics look stupid & discredit them.
I think it may seriously BACKFIRE on the pro-GW crowd in the long run. I sincerely hope it does!
I picked up The Age newspaper (a nation wide Aussie paper) today (Friday) and your name was in the article sourced from Reuters!
http://www.reuters.com/article/environmentNews/idUSL0887458220071108
http://www.theage.com.au/news/World/Hoax-study-tricks-some-climate-sceptics/2007/11/09/1194329503770.html
The Reuters piece quotes me as having made the "could not be more damaging" remark which, in fact was me quoting the spoof article itself. The second link shows how easy journalism can be when you just rewrite press releases - reminiscent of the way the media carelessly reports not what James Watson & Hasiltow actually said but what other media say they said.
Apparently Rush Limbaugh fell for it too.
This link suggests suggests some widespread alarmist conspiracy which I suspect is overstating it - Mr Thorpe may have had some help in producing what is a well produced hoax but I don't think we have to assume a massive conspiracy.
But
Numberwatch on the other hand was less impressed having immediately spotted that the formula given was nonsense.
No mention from the BBC, but I just heard somebody on Radio Scotland talking about the supermodel who demands to be paid in Euros not realising that it has already been proven a hoax so I guess I can be pleased to have been able to match their journalistic standards.
FURTHERER UPDATE
The hoax seems to have run its full cycle & it looks, as Pete said, that it has, on balance discredited the alarmists more than the sceptics as the editorial line in the New York Times article shows, precisely because it was so quickly rumbeled.
The article quotes Thorpe saying
"What we wanted to emphasize is that it’s necessary to achieve scientific validity using the peer-review model. Proper climate science makes every attempt to do this, and is a constantly evolving and self-refining process, as all science is.”
The use of the plural does indeed mean a certain level of conspiracy.
I commented on the NYT article that the discovery of this hoax compares very favourably with the Hockey Stick graph, used by the IPCC as their prime exhibit surviving for years, despite peer review, befors McIntyre proved it fraudulent.
Thorpe's own reaction on his blog quotes me saying the "could not be more damaging" which presumably means I am the most prominent blogger to have fallen for this, even for a short time. I do not fool myself as to my prominence. I have replied on his comments section.
"David it appears you are falling for part of your own hoax.
You quote me, Neil Craig at 'A Place to Stand' said "this paper could not be more damaging to manmade global warming theory" - now this comes from various newspaper articles which, in turn, are rewrites of the Reuters report in which it does indeed quote me as saying this. However a more careful reading of my post would have shown that I was not claiming this as my view but was instead taking it as a quote from your own article. You are therefore quoting the quote of the quote of myself republishing your quote, which you apparently didn't recognise.
I note you have said that "we" arranged this hoax & since it is indeed well constructed in the style of a genuine paper perhaps the other alarmist conspirators involved might like to take a public bow." We shall see if they do.
###########################################
This just received via CCNet so even if the MSM were going to report it the blogsphere would have it first. I somehow doubt if this is going to be on the BBC news.
Daniel A Klein*, Mandeep J Gupta*, Philip Cooper**, Arne FR Jansson**.
*Department of Climatology, University of Arizona;
**Department of Atmospheric Physics, Göteborgs Universitet (University of Gothenburg, Sweden.)
Received: 18 February 2007 / Accepted: 9th August 2007 / Published online: 3rd November 2007
Abstract
It is now well-established that rising global temperatures are largely the result of increasing concentrations of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. The "consensus" position attributes the increase in atmospheric CO2 to the combustion of fossil fuels by industrial processes. This is the mechanism which underpins the theory of manmade global warming.
Our data demonstrate that those who subscribe to the consensus theory have overlooked the primary source of carbon dioxide emissions. While a small part of the rise in emissions is attributable to industrial activity, it is greatly outweighed (by >300 times) by rising volumes of CO2 produced by saprotrophic eubacteria living in the sediments of the continental shelves fringing the Atlantic and Pacific oceans. Moreover, the bacterial emissions, unlike industrial CO2, precisely match the fluctuations in global temperature over the past 140 years. If under ocean bacteria are producing 300 times more CO2 than us then clearly our effect cannot dominant or even important.
Less importantly, since it is merely politics not science, are these remarks.
"Hat's off (we think) to UK writer and consultant David Thorpe, the apparent creator for the impressive web-based spoof - a definitive bit of climate change denial as reported in The Journal of Geoclimatic Studies.
Although the "journal" lists two volumes and some very tempting content*, the only research paper on the website is titled: "Carbon dioxide production by benthic bacteria: the death of manmade global warming theory?" The paper reports that rising volumes of CO2 are actually caused "by saprotrophic eubacteria living in the sediments of the continental shelves fringing the Atlantic and Pacific oceans."
Unfortunately, this wonderful news is attributed to a group of scientists who can't be found, working at a series of institutions or departments that don't exist."
Well Mr Thorpe I think the chance of this being mentioned by the BBC has just increased massively - they haven't reported the fact of 1998 being found no longer to be the warmest year on record, but would not be surprised to find them willing to report a hoax. There was a similar incident when "environmentalists" sent a signature to the 17,000 strong Oregon Petition of scientists denying catastrophic warming, in the name of Dr Geri Halliwell. Elsewhere I said that all that that proved is that the Oregon scientists weren't followers of the Spice Girls & that warming alarmists had no compunctions about fakery - neither of which reflect worse on the victims of the hoax than the perpetrators.
This is a much more subtle hoax but the point still stands. The speed of the reaction to their successful hoax is interesting. I would hope that more responsible alarmists, if that is not a contradiction in terms, will advise Mr Thorpe, assuming he is indeed the author, that this is not how science is done.
On the other hand they didn't object to the hoaxed "facts" in Mr Gore's film, which he may be about to assure us were also deliberate :-)
FURTHER UPDATE
Pete North has sent me the undernoted links from Australia.
"You were quite right about the hoax study now going to be all over the news worldwide- since it is obviously trying to make ALL of the GW sceptics look stupid & discredit them.
I think it may seriously BACKFIRE on the pro-GW crowd in the long run. I sincerely hope it does!
I picked up The Age newspaper (a nation wide Aussie paper) today (Friday) and your name was in the article sourced from Reuters!
http://www.reuters.com/article/environmentNews/idUSL0887458220071108
http://www.theage.com.au/news/World/Hoax-study-tricks-some-climate-sceptics/2007/11/09/1194329503770.html
The Reuters piece quotes me as having made the "could not be more damaging" remark which, in fact was me quoting the spoof article itself. The second link shows how easy journalism can be when you just rewrite press releases - reminiscent of the way the media carelessly reports not what James Watson & Hasiltow actually said but what other media say they said.
Apparently Rush Limbaugh fell for it too.
This link suggests suggests some widespread alarmist conspiracy which I suspect is overstating it - Mr Thorpe may have had some help in producing what is a well produced hoax but I don't think we have to assume a massive conspiracy.
But
Numberwatch on the other hand was less impressed having immediately spotted that the formula given was nonsense.
No mention from the BBC, but I just heard somebody on Radio Scotland talking about the supermodel who demands to be paid in Euros not realising that it has already been proven a hoax so I guess I can be pleased to have been able to match their journalistic standards.
FURTHERER UPDATE
The hoax seems to have run its full cycle & it looks, as Pete said, that it has, on balance discredited the alarmists more than the sceptics as the editorial line in the New York Times article shows, precisely because it was so quickly rumbeled.
The article quotes Thorpe saying
"What we wanted to emphasize is that it’s necessary to achieve scientific validity using the peer-review model. Proper climate science makes every attempt to do this, and is a constantly evolving and self-refining process, as all science is.”
The use of the plural does indeed mean a certain level of conspiracy.
I commented on the NYT article that the discovery of this hoax compares very favourably with the Hockey Stick graph, used by the IPCC as their prime exhibit surviving for years, despite peer review, befors McIntyre proved it fraudulent.
Thorpe's own reaction on his blog quotes me saying the "could not be more damaging" which presumably means I am the most prominent blogger to have fallen for this, even for a short time. I do not fool myself as to my prominence. I have replied on his comments section.
"David it appears you are falling for part of your own hoax.
You quote me, Neil Craig at 'A Place to Stand' said "this paper could not be more damaging to manmade global warming theory" - now this comes from various newspaper articles which, in turn, are rewrites of the Reuters report in which it does indeed quote me as saying this. However a more careful reading of my post would have shown that I was not claiming this as my view but was instead taking it as a quote from your own article. You are therefore quoting the quote of the quote of myself republishing your quote, which you apparently didn't recognise.
I note you have said that "we" arranged this hoax & since it is indeed well constructed in the style of a genuine paper perhaps the other alarmist conspirators involved might like to take a public bow." We shall see if they do.
###########################################
This just received via CCNet so even if the MSM were going to report it the blogsphere would have it first. I somehow doubt if this is going to be on the BBC news.
Daniel A Klein*, Mandeep J Gupta*, Philip Cooper**, Arne FR Jansson**.
*Department of Climatology, University of Arizona;
**Department of Atmospheric Physics, Göteborgs Universitet (University of Gothenburg, Sweden.)
Received: 18 February 2007 / Accepted: 9th August 2007 / Published online: 3rd November 2007
Abstract
It is now well-established that rising global temperatures are largely the result of increasing concentrations of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. The "consensus" position attributes the increase in atmospheric CO2 to the combustion of fossil fuels by industrial processes. This is the mechanism which underpins the theory of manmade global warming.
Our data demonstrate that those who subscribe to the consensus theory have overlooked the primary source of carbon dioxide emissions. While a small part of the rise in emissions is attributable to industrial activity, it is greatly outweighed (by >300 times) by rising volumes of CO2 produced by saprotrophic eubacteria living in the sediments of the continental shelves fringing the Atlantic and Pacific oceans. Moreover, the bacterial emissions, unlike industrial CO2, precisely match the fluctuations in global temperature over the past 140 years. If under ocean bacteria are producing 300 times more CO2 than us then clearly our effect cannot dominant or even important.
Less importantly, since it is merely politics not science, are these remarks.
It was not our intention in researching this issue to disprove manmade global warming theory. We have received no funds, directly or indirectly, from fossil fuel companies and have no personal interest in the outcome of the debate. We simply noticed an anomaly in the figures used by those who accept the "consensus" position on climate change and sought to investigate it. But the findings presented in this paper could not be more damaging to manmade global warming theory or to the thousands of climate scientists who have overlooked - sometimes, we fear, deliberately - the anomaly. We have found a near-perfect match between the levels of carbon dioxide produced by benthic eubacteria and recent global temperature records. By contrast we note what must be obvious to all those who have studied the figures with an open mind: a very poor match between carbon dioxide produced by burning fossil fuels and recent global temperature records......
These findings place us in a difficult position. We feel an obligation to publish, both in the cause of scientific objectivity and to prevent a terrible mistake - with extremely costly implications - from being made by the world's governments. But we recognise that in doing so, we lay our careers on the line. As we have found in seeking to broach this issue gently with colleagues, and in attempting to publish these findings in other peer-reviewed journals, the "consensus" on climate change is enforced not by fact but by fear. We have been warned, collectively and individually, that in bringing our findings to public attention we are not only likely to be deprived of all future sources of funding, but that we also jeopardise the funding of the departments for which we work.
We believe that academic intimidation of this kind contradicts the spirit of open enquiry in which scientific investigations should be conducted. We deplore the aggressive responses we encountered before our findings were published, and fear the reaction this paper might provoke. But dangerous as these findings are, we feel we have no choice but to publish.
Comments:
This article gives the light in which we can observe the reality. this is very nice one and gives in-depth information. Thanks for this nice article. Regards
term paper writing service
<< Home
This paper is a rather elaborate hoax. Neither the authors nor the "peer-reviewed" journal actually exist.
Regards,
Mike Asher
Dailytech.com
Regards,
Mike Asher
Dailytech.com
The opening sentence of their abstract seems to me to be untrue. Moreover, I am sceptical whenever good agreement is claimed with temperature measurements that seem themselves to be pretty flawed. Nonetheless, it's quite a stunning argument they are making. It reminds me that the Global Warming scare is such a scam that there must be potentially many sorts of argument that could hole it below the waterline. I suppose I'd better look at their paper.
Lest my previous remarks seem a bit grudging, I should say that if their argument survives scrutiny, it should be Nobel prizes and honorary knighthoods all round. Plus the public defenestration of all the crooks in the Global Warmongering camp.
I am a professor of atmospheric Sciencs at the university of arizona, and can say with certainty that 1) There is NO department of Climatology at UA, 2) there is noone by the name of Daniel Klein at the university, and 3) The journal of geoclimatology is a fabrication -- the editorial board has fictitious names as well.
Check it out:
http://www.arizona.edu/
Do a search for Daniel Klein
Check it out:
http://www.arizona.edu/
Do a search for Daniel Klein
Hook, line, and sinker, I see.
Now you can research some real science, rather than playing at journalist.
Now you can research some real science, rather than playing at journalist.
Hi Neil,
Just wanted you to know that this study is a hoax intended to show how gullible the global climate change deniers are. You probably noticed a bunch of hits to this post, this is because the blogosphere is making fun of you. You may wish to publish a retraction.
--john
Just wanted you to know that this study is a hoax intended to show how gullible the global climate change deniers are. You probably noticed a bunch of hits to this post, this is because the blogosphere is making fun of you. You may wish to publish a retraction.
--john
Uhhhh... have you figured out that this was a hoax paper with made-up terms and made-up authors?
Like it really matters if the rise in global temps were man-made or not... which planet are you and your children living on once this one is cooked?
Like it really matters if the rise in global temps were man-made or not... which planet are you and your children living on once this one is cooked?
OMG so cool except it is fake, try finding the authors. Mandeep Gupta doesn't exist at U of Arizona.
I doubt you're smart enough to even understand that study, let alone judge it's quality. In fact, I know it!
It won't be published on BBC news because it's not real. See here:
http://www.desmogblog.com/spoof-website-touts-global-warming-death-were-you-duped
http://www.desmogblog.com/spoof-website-touts-global-warming-death-were-you-duped
Sorry to tell you this but apparently this is a spoof - you are referenced on a nasty little site as having taken the bait - see http://www.desmogblog.com/spoof-website-touts-global-warming-death-were-you-duped
Sincerely,
Tom Harris, B. Eng., M. Eng. (thermofluids)
Executive Director
Natural Resources Stewardship Project
P.O. Box 23013
Ottawa, Ontario K2A 4E2
e-mail: tom.harris@nrsp.com
Web: www.nrsp.com
Sincerely,
Tom Harris, B. Eng., M. Eng. (thermofluids)
Executive Director
Natural Resources Stewardship Project
P.O. Box 23013
Ottawa, Ontario K2A 4E2
e-mail: tom.harris@nrsp.com
Web: www.nrsp.com
Paper's a fake, I suggest you do a quick search on the name of the journal or the purported scientists.
Neil, here's an idea: in order to discredit all "Global Warming" skeptics, how about saying that they are "all in the pay of the big oil companies"?
Still doesn't work? How about comparing all of them to "Holocaust deniers" (a la Marko Attila Hoare & Oliver Kamm of the UK Henry Jackson Society)maliciously labelling as "Holocaust deniers" all those independent researchers who "deny" that the late Bosnian muslim "president", Alija Izetbegovic, was "a moderate, secular, Western-oriented liberal committed to a multi-ethnic democracy" and who expose Izetbegovic's own writings and actions to prove that he was an Islamofascist WW2 Nazi SS collaborator, whom like Franjo Tudjman, was openly dedicated to genocide of the Serbs in Bosnia, Krajina & Croatia?
If that still doesn't silence these stubborn "Global Warming deniers",how about sending them death threats via e-mail?
Darn it, looks like that's been done already!
"...In examining that there is more evidence to prove the basis for a conclusion that changes in climate are more related to an increase in the temperature of the Sun rather than influence of people, we must examine why efforts to expose this myth are stifled and those who speak out are attacked.
"In fact, there are reported cases of scientists who speak out against the man-made theory as having received death threats.
"There has even been talk of relating those who speak out against the currently held theory on global warming as being equal to those who deny the Holocaust.
"In a recent op-ed piece in the Boston Globe commenting on the report issued by the UN, Ellen Goodman wrote, “Let's just say that global warming deniers are now on a par with Holocaust deniers, though one denies the past and the other denies the present and future.”
"This is a very disturbing comment, not only because there is reason to scientifically doubt the man-made theory, but also because this is a scathing attack on freedom of speech, the most vital and important of all rights and freedoms."
Global Warming: A Convenient Lie
by Andrew G. Marshall
Global Research, March 15, 2007
http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=va&aid=5086
[Excerpt]
"...It seems worrisome that politicians are all too eager to grab onto this man-made myth of global warming in order to make us afraid and guilty. Guilty enough to want to change it, and afraid enough to give up our freedoms and undergo massive financial expenses in order to do so.
"So this lie, being pushed by big money and big governments, is a convenient lie for those who want to exert control and collect money.
"However, it’s inconvenient for the mass amount of people who are already experiencing the problems of a widening wage-gap and fading middle class.
"...Timothy Ball, one of the first Canadian doctors in climatology, recently wrote an article addressing the issue of why no one seems to be listening to scientists who claim that global warming is NOT man-made.
He starts by writing, “Believe it or not, Global Warming is not due to human contribution of Carbon Dioxide (CO2). This in fact is the greatest deception in the history of science”. He continues, “We are wasting time, energy and trillions of dollars while creating unnecessary fear and consternation over an issue with no scientific justification.”
Then he mentions how Environment Canada is spending billions upon billions of dollars on “propaganda” which defends an “indefensible scientific position while at the same time closing weather stations and failing to meet legisl
Still doesn't work? How about comparing all of them to "Holocaust deniers" (a la Marko Attila Hoare & Oliver Kamm of the UK Henry Jackson Society)maliciously labelling as "Holocaust deniers" all those independent researchers who "deny" that the late Bosnian muslim "president", Alija Izetbegovic, was "a moderate, secular, Western-oriented liberal committed to a multi-ethnic democracy" and who expose Izetbegovic's own writings and actions to prove that he was an Islamofascist WW2 Nazi SS collaborator, whom like Franjo Tudjman, was openly dedicated to genocide of the Serbs in Bosnia, Krajina & Croatia?
If that still doesn't silence these stubborn "Global Warming deniers",how about sending them death threats via e-mail?
Darn it, looks like that's been done already!
"...In examining that there is more evidence to prove the basis for a conclusion that changes in climate are more related to an increase in the temperature of the Sun rather than influence of people, we must examine why efforts to expose this myth are stifled and those who speak out are attacked.
"In fact, there are reported cases of scientists who speak out against the man-made theory as having received death threats.
"There has even been talk of relating those who speak out against the currently held theory on global warming as being equal to those who deny the Holocaust.
"In a recent op-ed piece in the Boston Globe commenting on the report issued by the UN, Ellen Goodman wrote, “Let's just say that global warming deniers are now on a par with Holocaust deniers, though one denies the past and the other denies the present and future.”
"This is a very disturbing comment, not only because there is reason to scientifically doubt the man-made theory, but also because this is a scathing attack on freedom of speech, the most vital and important of all rights and freedoms."
Global Warming: A Convenient Lie
by Andrew G. Marshall
Global Research, March 15, 2007
http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=va&aid=5086
[Excerpt]
"...It seems worrisome that politicians are all too eager to grab onto this man-made myth of global warming in order to make us afraid and guilty. Guilty enough to want to change it, and afraid enough to give up our freedoms and undergo massive financial expenses in order to do so.
"So this lie, being pushed by big money and big governments, is a convenient lie for those who want to exert control and collect money.
"However, it’s inconvenient for the mass amount of people who are already experiencing the problems of a widening wage-gap and fading middle class.
"...Timothy Ball, one of the first Canadian doctors in climatology, recently wrote an article addressing the issue of why no one seems to be listening to scientists who claim that global warming is NOT man-made.
He starts by writing, “Believe it or not, Global Warming is not due to human contribution of Carbon Dioxide (CO2). This in fact is the greatest deception in the history of science”. He continues, “We are wasting time, energy and trillions of dollars while creating unnecessary fear and consternation over an issue with no scientific justification.”
Then he mentions how Environment Canada is spending billions upon billions of dollars on “propaganda” which defends an “indefensible scientific position while at the same time closing weather stations and failing to meet legisl
If the paper is indeed a hoax, then it only further confirms that the phony "global warming" environmental fascist crowd are getting really, intensely desperate; using the rather crude CIA-FBI COINTELPRO methods of creating elaborate hoaxes in order to ridicule, attempt to discredit and stifle legitimate dissent and public opposition to their fascist environmental agenda: nearly all of it based on an avalanche of egregious lies!
After all, all you merely did was post an article you received in good faith via CCnET. Big deal.
The peurile,imbecilic commentators above ridiculing you in such a childish,infantile manner should be ashamed of themselves! It just goes to show how dishonest and desperate these phony "global warming" people are.
Google COINTELPRO
http://www.whatreallyhappened.com/RANCHO/POLITICS/COINTELPRO/cointelpro.html
http://www.icdc.com/~paulwolf/cointelpro/cointel.htm
http://www.whatreallyhappened.com/RANCHO/POLITICS/COINTELPRO/cointelpro-methods.html
After all, all you merely did was post an article you received in good faith via CCnET. Big deal.
The peurile,imbecilic commentators above ridiculing you in such a childish,infantile manner should be ashamed of themselves! It just goes to show how dishonest and desperate these phony "global warming" people are.
Google COINTELPRO
http://www.whatreallyhappened.com/RANCHO/POLITICS/COINTELPRO/cointelpro.html
http://www.icdc.com/~paulwolf/cointelpro/cointel.htm
http://www.whatreallyhappened.com/RANCHO/POLITICS/COINTELPRO/cointelpro-methods.html
The "we" is not a conspiracy. It is simply that Thorpe had a consultant working on the paper with him...hence the "we." Again, jumping to conclusions...
"If the paper is indeed a hoax, then it only further confirms that the phony "global warming" environmental fascist crowd are getting really, intensely desperate"
Well no Andrew, it proves that the deniers will jump on any old rubbish that somehow supports their assertions, whereas everyone else relies on proven, published research.
Admit it mate, you've been found out.
Well no Andrew, it proves that the deniers will jump on any old rubbish that somehow supports their assertions, whereas everyone else relies on proven, published research.
Admit it mate, you've been found out.
"Well no Andrew, it proves that the deniers will jump on any old rubbish that somehow supports their assertions, whereas everyone else relies on proven, published research.
Admit it mate, you've been found out."
Well, no "finite",sir, it actually proves that you and the delusional "Global Warming" environmentalist fascist crowd does not have any valid scientific arguments which hold water (i.e., those based on irrefutable scientific facts instead of "junk science") which can withstand close scrutiny: otherwise the delusional "Global Warming" liars being bought and paid for (i.e., "funded") by Big Government would not have to resort to dishonest CIA-FBI COINTELPRO style tactics: namely, by producing elaborate hoaxes.
Admit it "finite", the jig is up and you and your ecological fascist friends of Big Government have been thoroughly exposed for what you really are:a bunch of pathetic, egregious,shameless liars.
Admit it mate, you've been found out."
Well, no "finite",sir, it actually proves that you and the delusional "Global Warming" environmentalist fascist crowd does not have any valid scientific arguments which hold water (i.e., those based on irrefutable scientific facts instead of "junk science") which can withstand close scrutiny: otherwise the delusional "Global Warming" liars being bought and paid for (i.e., "funded") by Big Government would not have to resort to dishonest CIA-FBI COINTELPRO style tactics: namely, by producing elaborate hoaxes.
Admit it "finite", the jig is up and you and your ecological fascist friends of Big Government have been thoroughly exposed for what you really are:a bunch of pathetic, egregious,shameless liars.
This seems to provide a useful overview of the hoax.
http://newsbusters.org/blogs/amy-ridenour/2007/11/09/fake-global-warming-study-fools-four-reuters-runs-wire-story
Apparently it took the developer of the hoax 4 days to put the paper together - worth it eh?
David thorpe is still working as a Guardian journalist.
http://newsbusters.org/blogs/amy-ridenour/2007/11/09/fake-global-warming-study-fools-four-reuters-runs-wire-story
Apparently it took the developer of the hoax 4 days to put the paper together - worth it eh?
David thorpe is still working as a Guardian journalist.
Many institutions limit access to their online information. Making this information available will be an asset to all.
Many institutions limit access to their online information. Making this information available will be an asset to all.
Many institutions limit access to their online information. Making this information available will be an asset to all.
Global warming it is a disputed topic these days. I don't have an opinion yet. I have just listened to others so far. The temperature as I have noticed has changed. I gets warmer, due to all the machinery and appliances that we are using. The truth is that this year, in Eastern Europe, the temperature has not grown so much. It has been a warm summer, but we had plenty of rain. Now is just the begining of September and you have to have a jacket now to go outside. Of course, you cannot made an opinion just after the temperature of one year.
The Medieval Warming Period was certainly 1 - 1.5 degreess warmer than now & the Climate Optimum (9,000 to 5,000 BC) was up to 4 degrees warmer. Neither was "catastrophic", indeed they were quite prosperous, so we can be certain that uless or until warming pushing these limits is observed the entire scare story is a fraud.
Nice observation, thanks. I don’t visit your blog every day, but when .Visit your blog I enjoy browsing through your posts. Keep posting..
Hello my friend! I want to say that this article is awesome, nice written and include almost all vital info. I would like to see more posts like this.
Brilliant article.Thank you so much for the share. i really like the way the author write the article
Cheap essay writing service
Cheap essay writing service
Wonderful post ;)By the way, , here is a greta place to get top-quality papers.
Regards, Custom-Essays-Online.com ;)
Regards, Custom-Essays-Online.com ;)
This article gives the light in which we can observe the reality. this is very nice one and gives in-depth information. Thanks for this nice article. Regards
term paper writing service
well Nice going. You have certainly proved something with this post. A lot of people will notice. Halloween Costumes
I've enjoyed reading the post. It is very informative and useful post. I think this is a really good article. sudoapp.com
Due to Perfect Essay wriitng company reputation of being the best custom writing resource, there are a well sought after essay writing service amid the customers all over the world. If you're looking for the internet's leading custom writing service you've come to exactly the right place!
Excellent post share with us and this blog is impresses more people to reading that blog. find a debtor
The first and foremost thing is an education. american-writers.org essay writing service introduces you to the skills you might never learn whilst at school or college.
Although the "journal" lists two volumes and some very tempting content*, the only research paper on the website is titled: "Carbon dioxide production by benthic bacteria. Literature Review Writing Help
This is a much more subtle hoax but the point still stands. The speed of the reaction to their successful hoax is interesting. Buy law essays
Excellent post share with us and this blog is impresses more people to reading that blog. Ghana News
Cheers. Great post!! i must say and thanks for the tips. Post that you talk about this very nice, the welcome mat
You can order custom assignment by giving all the little details case study assignment help to the writer yourself. This will ensure that the paper done by us is exactly how you want it.
Thanks a lot for sharing your aticle. I have found it by chance, and to be honest I am going to miss Obama and how professional he was. Well, I got the task ti write an essay about his carreer and that was wonderful to get Best Support From College Paper Writing Service
very excellent post aplikasi android keren
model baju wanita
cara cek kuota
tampilan bbm android
manfaat buah naga
manfaat buah lemon
model baju wanita
cara cek kuota
tampilan bbm android
manfaat buah naga
manfaat buah lemon
Private moneylenders will give payday credits to anybody, which is one reason they are so well known.
So what are the pitfalls of such advances? Relatively few in the event that you keep to the assention, in spite of the fact that it is what could be your destruction.
On the off chance that you are burnt out on meeting huge amounts of prerequisites to apply for an advance, this advance is for you as well. Auto title credits just oblige you to submit few and fundamental necessities.
I want to say that I am grateful to the author for the good work. I think work should always be marked by quality.
We feel much concerned of the value of your property, safety and security more than our profit or anything else, actually dedicated to our services click here https://www.ajrinconstruction.com/bathroom-remodeling/ and hold out till our Clients’ functions are served to satisfaction.
over here
over here
This is a substantially more unpretentious scam yet the point still stands. The speed of the response to their effective lie is intriguing.
Your opinion about global warming theory is realy interesting. Can you write more about Mr Thorpe. This topic is important for me, I tryed write essey, but it is not for me. So I asked https://writer-elite.com/scholarship-essay/ for help. They are really cool and professional people. So I am interested by this topic. I will be thank you for help)
Very interesting article. I like posts like this, where you can get a lot of useful information. I found one more site with interesting content - https://www.behance.net/gallery/66027747/Political-Campaign-Communications
Your conclusion about a worldwide temperature alteration hypothesis is extremely intriguing. This point is essential to me, I attempted to compose a paper, yet it isn't for me. So I approached https://topwritingservice.com/buy-research-paper/ for help. They are extremely cool and expert individuals. So I am occupied with this subject. I will be thank you for help
You will defenitely like this article http://www.johnplafon.com/technology-and-education/ Check it out
Hey there! I adore your blog. I hope you will publish more posts like this one. Also, I want recommend one website that is called https://premium-quality-essays.com/annotated-bibliography-writing.html.
How to Check BSNL Number
How to Check BSNL Number
Happy Birthday Mom Wishes
Laptops Under 500 dollars
Laptops Under 400 dollars
Laptops Under 300 dollars
Laptops Under 200 dollars
How to Check BSNL Number
Happy Birthday Mom Wishes
Laptops Under 500 dollars
Laptops Under 400 dollars
Laptops Under 300 dollars
Laptops Under 200 dollars
TechkyUniverse Dhruvtiwari Official Dhruvhat Wordpress Dhruvhat Livejournal TechkyUniverse Blog dhruvhat Wixsite techkyuniverse Yolasite TechkyUniverse Wikidot TechkyUniverse Weebly TechkyUniverse Strikingly
Thank you for sharing with us this informative post! By the way, we are always ready to help you with writing papers on any kinds!
I read your blog post.. and this is one of the best blog post. so thanks a lot for sharing this post. Assignment Help ireland
These posts are very useful to go through and I am eager to read some more content like this. Images are very eye catchy and love the display of content being done by the author would love to get some more of like this.
best mail order nurseries
best mail order nurseries
Does Finance Assignment affect your personal finance? Due to fines and modifications, if your financial prospects are not good, then give us a chance, we will ensure high grade and savings and increase in healthy personal finance and provide you the best quality content. So avail our Assignment help online by the native writer of Singapore Assignment Help.
Hey, your article is really great. Submit your assignment before the time limit, so they choose to purchase available assignment services for her. Students can get the assignment help from AbAssignmentHelp in Uk to complete their assignments.
For your PC ultimate protection, you can use the Webroot antivirus trial version free from Webroot website www.webroot.com/safe. You can protect your system against viruses, threats, malware and more online threats.
Weightlifting exercises are great to increase your strength in your legs and core which are essential to being able to propel. of this extra strength. This article might explain more fully. Star Lord Leather Jacket
Yes i cant wait for fifa. ive looked at the trailers and it looks awesome. i am getting it the day it comes out. im going to go reserve it today. Arthur Morgan Jacket
Really great article!
Here you can find useful information about cell phone tracking apps www.spy-apps-software.com
Here you can find useful information about cell phone tracking apps www.spy-apps-software.com
It also makes me feel kind of good when I can answer a question and find out it helped someone. Baywatch Bomber Jacket
Yes its hard as its an Asian language. But if you are a Chinese speaker it will be very easy to learn Korean because there are a lot of. Sherlock Coat
I am amazed by the way you have explained things in this article. This article is quite interesting and I am looking forward to reading more of your posts. Thanks for sharing this article with us.Anne Hathaway Fur Brown Coat
The surprisingly excellent site - GameMS, the best online game coin dealer for online video games, can bring you the latest Internet business experience, discover more quality products, place orders immediately, and enjoy discounted prices.
hp is one of the most trusted brand in the world.Reach our hp customer support team for getting quick assistance from the team of professional experts.Get instant solution at hp support phone number is available 24*7 in usa.
HP Customer Service
HP Customer Service phone number
HP printer support number
HP Support number
HP Customer Service
HP Customer Service phone number
HP printer support number
HP Support number
Great posts! I am actually getting ready to across this information, is very helpful my friend. Bad Boys For Life Mike Lowrey Jacket
https://creativehealthcart.lighthouseapp.com/projects/142676-creative-health-cart/tickets/1-creative-health-cart
http://www.saanimees.ee/viewtopic.php?f=7&t=118157
https://www.basketballcoach.com/coaching/read.php?2,26499
https://www.becomingadatascientist.com/learningclub/thread-475346.html
https://yarabook.com/read-blog/37096
http://www.snooth.com/talk/topic/creative-health-cart-1/
https://www.postgraduateforum.com/thread-57275
https://gumroad.com/l/creativehealthcartbuy
http://www.dreevoo.com/forum_post.php?idt=14988
http://www.mre-books.com/cgi-bin/teemz/teemz.cgi?board=ranger&action=opentopic&topic=1854&forum=discussion_Forum
http://www.saanimees.ee/viewtopic.php?f=7&t=118157
https://www.basketballcoach.com/coaching/read.php?2,26499
https://www.becomingadatascientist.com/learningclub/thread-475346.html
https://yarabook.com/read-blog/37096
http://www.snooth.com/talk/topic/creative-health-cart-1/
https://www.postgraduateforum.com/thread-57275
https://gumroad.com/l/creativehealthcartbuy
http://www.dreevoo.com/forum_post.php?idt=14988
http://www.mre-books.com/cgi-bin/teemz/teemz.cgi?board=ranger&action=opentopic&topic=1854&forum=discussion_Forum
It was not first article by this author as I always found him as a talented author. Poe Dameron Jacket
Don't miss the grand sale on Cotton Jacket and coat. Shop this Mike Lowrey jacket and avail flat 40% off on all the leather products with free shipping.
Buy this premium quality Bad Boys For Life Will Smith Jacket from our online Fashion Hub famousjacket. Shop and get up to 80% off on selected leather jackets and coats.
If you are willing lean six sigma certification in india consult beingcert. Goldberg Harley Davidson Jacket
Don't miss the grand sale on Cotton Jacket and coat. Shop this Negative Man Trench Coat and avail flat 40% off on all the leather products with free shipping.
I am amazed by the way you have explained things in this article. This article is quite interesting and I am looking forward to reading more of your posts. Thanks for sharing this article with us.Star Trek Picard Jeri Ryan Leather Jacket
Computer Assignment writing is the task which frequently gives students a tension. If you are going through from the same. Then in such situation, you can choose our computer network assignment help service and can get a quality assignment written from us.
programming assignment help - An assignment of IT is a degree to uncover new data and reveal the realities which could be an equal report alongside embedding it by making new region of IT application. He begins hating his school or school. Along these lines, it is prudent for students to look for proficient law assignment helps law assignment help in seeing how legitimate speculations and ideas can be implemented in reality. It tries to direct us about forthcoming change on the laws across courts, policing, organizations, legitimate firms, and security offices.
Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking. Movies Jackets
Just wish to say your article is as surprising.the submit is simply excellent and i can assume you are knowledgeable in this subject. Freddie Mercury Jacket
Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking..... Celebrity Movie Jacket
Cooperation is very nice thing that takes you at very high level of respect. If you respect others, than other peoples are respect you in the form of double. Similarly if you are director of any company, hotel or restaurant than you should be polite to staff if you want to successful because if you respect your staff then they work as their own company. Dark Knight Rises Bane Coat
pure skills and the wonderful information keep it up.
Essay Writer
Is It Safe To Hire Essay Writer From Canada?
Essay Writer
Is It Safe To Hire Essay Writer From Canada?
Blog Black Friday
blackfriday sales on msi gtx 1070
nikon d3500 bundle deals black friday
best projector deals for black friday 2020
kitchen appliance packages black friday
kohls black friday sales 2020
acer x34 predator
projector deals black friday
4k monitor black friday
asus rog swift pg279q drivers
blackfriday sales on msi gtx 1070
nikon d3500 bundle deals black friday
best projector deals for black friday 2020
kitchen appliance packages black friday
kohls black friday sales 2020
acer x34 predator
projector deals black friday
4k monitor black friday
asus rog swift pg279q drivers
looking for trending products at affordable prices?? if yes then visit us for quality products online.
Buy Dimmable Vanity Lights
Hair Straightener Brush Online
hair removal machine online
Buy Dimmable Vanity Lights
Hair Straightener Brush Online
hair removal machine online
thanks for this best post keep share the good information with us.
Buy Essay from UK Site
Essay Help UK
Buy Essay from UK Site
Essay Help UK
Assignment Help in Perth
f you want to get best Assignment Help in Perth then consult with Assignment Help Experts and get best Assingnment Writing Help in Perth. We offer best Assignment Services in All over Australia.. https://www.thetutorshelp.com/assignment-help-in-perth.php
f you want to get best Assignment Help in Perth then consult with Assignment Help Experts and get best Assingnment Writing Help in Perth. We offer best Assignment Services in All over Australia.. https://www.thetutorshelp.com/assignment-help-in-perth.php
Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. I'm happy I found this blog. Jennifer Lopez Leather Jacket
I am so happy to come across this piece of write up, very much advanced my understanding to the next top level. Great job and continue to do same.Sonic The Hedgehog Hoodie
The format of the assignment is set up according to the necessity. Our assignment help offers types of assistance including particular, recommendations, and plausibility in the paper. We recruit top assignment writers through a thorough interaction so we can guarantee you with the excellent substance. We do the entirety of this at most moderate costs as we comprehend students will not have the option to address significant expenses as they don't procure that much. myassignmenthelp
Structural Analysis - It is the part of mechanical engineering that inspects the exhibition of the various articles, plans, and machinery. It manages the disappointment and the investigation of the individual parts in two unique modes, specifically, static disappointment and weariness disappointment. To obtain itemized information regarding the matter, you can contact our mechanical assignment help specialists for mechanical engineering homework help. assignment provider
assignment help melbourne
assignment help melbourne
The writers at ABC Assignment Help offer assignment help for critical essay, which is linguistically right and expertly gave a reliable and clear contention and exact references to help it. This records for an essay writing which exhibits cautious perusing of a source, comprehension of the topic and assessment of the proof identified with that subject. essay writing help , assignmenthelp
Superb post, thanks for this.Do share more updates.
Ozpaperhelp is leading and most popular name in uk for assignment help services.
Assignment writing help at professional writing company.
Operating System Assignment Help
Write My Assignment for Me
Optometrists Assignment Help
Chemical Engineering Assignment Help
Statistics Assignment Help
SAS Assignment Help By SAS Experts
CDR Engineers Australia
CDR Report Writers
Arts Assignment Help
Arts Architecture Assignment Help
Auditing Assignment Help
Anthropology Assignment Help
Anthropology Assignment Help
PYTHON Assignment Help
HTML Assignment Help
All Assignment Help
MySQL Assignment Help
Ozpaperhelp is leading and most popular name in uk for assignment help services.
Assignment writing help at professional writing company.
Operating System Assignment Help
Write My Assignment for Me
Optometrists Assignment Help
Chemical Engineering Assignment Help
Statistics Assignment Help
SAS Assignment Help By SAS Experts
CDR Engineers Australia
CDR Report Writers
Arts Assignment Help
Arts Architecture Assignment Help
Auditing Assignment Help
Anthropology Assignment Help
Anthropology Assignment Help
PYTHON Assignment Help
HTML Assignment Help
All Assignment Help
MySQL Assignment Help
ABC Assignment Help is a bespoke online instructive trim connection offering able task help to understudies seeking after courses in schools and colleges of Australia, UK, USA, Canada and New Zealand. 100% attestation help with attempting it NOW
I appreciate you so much for sharing this invaluable information. I am cheering to discover your post. We are the Best CDR Report provider for Engineers Australia. Visit CDR Australia for accurate information. We also provide RPL Writing Services.
Kindly mail us at Contact@CDRAustralia.Org
Kindly mail us at Contact@CDRAustralia.Org
No reference structure
Our freelance project writers in Brisbane can format your custom work in all sorts of contexts, including APA, Chicago, Harvard, MLA, Oxford and more. State your needs, and our assignment writing experts in Australia will bring you back with the right assignment.
100% privacy.
We make your privacy a top priority. Unlike other assignment support service providers in Brisbane that use customer information for greater profit, Thetutorshelp.com never sells or discusses student information with a third party. Your personal details are protected by us in every way.
Assignment Help in Brisbane
Our freelance project writers in Brisbane can format your custom work in all sorts of contexts, including APA, Chicago, Harvard, MLA, Oxford and more. State your needs, and our assignment writing experts in Australia will bring you back with the right assignment.
100% privacy.
We make your privacy a top priority. Unlike other assignment support service providers in Brisbane that use customer information for greater profit, Thetutorshelp.com never sells or discusses student information with a third party. Your personal details are protected by us in every way.
Assignment Help in Brisbane
We are an effective online biochemistry assignment help association which offers uncommon help on homework and assignments. Around here at ABC Assignment Help, we have encountered and qualified specialists online, who works nonstop to ensure that you get the best plausible assignment help arrangements. do my assignment
I want to say thank you for taking your time and energy to put this article together. Once again, I find myself spending a lot of time in reading this post. Thanks for sharing. Meanwhile you can check your absu cut off mark for electrical engineering
My decision to apply for Payday Loans in Kentucky was motivated by my desire to get closer to my goal. After looking into everything, I believe I'll grant a loan for a car model I've fallen in love with.
Thank you for posting such a great article! I found your website perfect for my needs.Love Hard Barb Lin Puffer Coat
I am so happy to come across this piece of write up, very much advanced my understanding to the next top level. Great job and continue to do same.James Dutton Yellowstone 1883 Fur Coat
Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. I'm happy I found this blog.
Red Notice Dwayne Johnson Maroon Blazer
Red Notice Dwayne Johnson Maroon Blazer
Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. I'm happy I found this blog.
James Nesbitt Stay Close 2021 Blue Cotton Jacket
James Nesbitt Stay Close 2021 Blue Cotton Jacket
Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. I'm happy I found this blog.Rip Wheeler Leather Coat
I constantly read the smaller articles as well as clarify their motives, and that also happens with this article!
Cobra Kai Jacket Red
Cobra Kai Jacket Red
This absolutely amazing, you got true and fresh information posted here, really found it useful, thanks for posting and the effort! Please keep sharing more of such blogs. ielts nigeria past questions and answers pdf download
I really enjoyed reading your article. I found this as an informative and interesting post.Uhtred The Last Kingdom Leather Costume
I enjoyed reading this .Thanks for sharing and keep writing. It is good to read blogs like thisWomen Leather 3/4 Leather Coat
Very nice article, I enjoyed reading your post, very nice share, I want to twit this to my followers. Thanks!.Adam Project Clothing
I constantly read the smaller articles as well as clarify their motives, and that also happens with this article!Movie Leather Jackets
I enjoyed reading this .Thanks for sharing and keep writing. It is good to read blogs like thisKevin Costner Black Vest
Thanks for giving this excellent information, you have a very good post. Such a lovely posting.Cullen Bohannon Vest
Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. I'm happy I found this blog.Johnny Lawrence Red Jacket
Pretty cool post. It’s really very nice and useful post. Keep it up!!
Bane Tom Hardy The Dark Knight Rises 2012 Leather Coat
Bane Tom Hardy The Dark Knight Rises 2012 Leather Coat
Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. I'm happy I found this blog.Michelle Dockery Black Coat
This post is really informative and you have posted such precious and informative article.Longmire Jacket
a bathing ape
kobe sneakers
golden goose outlet
supreme clothing
golden goose sneakers
air jordan
supreme hoodie
yeezy shoes
golden goose starter
kyrie irving
kobe sneakers
golden goose outlet
supreme clothing
golden goose sneakers
air jordan
supreme hoodie
yeezy shoes
golden goose starter
kyrie irving
This is really a great website, i suggest you to post articles to attract visitors attention. Your website is really a great source of information Josh Lucas Yellowstone Quilted Jacket
This paper is extremely damaging. It is full of well-researched facts and compelling arguments that make it hard to deny. ipvanish coupon code It is a very powerful tool to bring about the necessary change.
The team of professionals at Assignment Help Sheffield understands the importance of deadlines, and they work diligently to ensure that the students receive their work on time.
In summary, Assignment Help Sheffield is an excellent service for students who need academic assistance in Sheffield, UK. The service provides high-quality, timely, and affordable academic assistance that meets the highest academic standards.
Assignment Help Sheffield
In summary, Assignment Help Sheffield is an excellent service for students who need academic assistance in Sheffield, UK. The service provides high-quality, timely, and affordable academic assistance that meets the highest academic standards.
Assignment Help Sheffield
Wow! What a blog! I was having problem coping up with my studies and one of my friend recommended this website to me. Since then all my problems have subsided as you guys have done the work perfectly. I would surely be recommending this website to every friend of mine as it would reduce their stress and sleeping problems in no time. I am very happy with your efforts and I am here to use your services for 5th time now. Thank you once again for posting such article and making the lives of struggling students easier.
Online Law Assignment Help
Online Law Assignment Help
Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. I'm happy I found this blog. Jennifer Lopez Leather Jacket. I am very impressed to see your interview I watched your complete interview when you are free check my comments and visit my store.Shopi Fit
There are so many world problems which need to be addressed but a particular issue was given light in Egpyt towards the latter stages of last year; COP27 was the name of the meeting. The year before held a convention in Scotlands capital, Glasgow. The capital of Personal Injury Claims Scotland is us. Contact us today.
Readers may now get a detailed glimpse into the life of one of the most well-known Private Investigators of all time thanks to the publication of a new explosive book on Jane Mugo. Investigative journalist Maria Smith's book, which explores some of Mugo's most notable cases and offers a window into her own hardships, is written. Exclusive interviews with Mugo's former clients, associates, and even some of the individuals she successfully prosecuted are also included in the book. It gives the impression of a determined and persistent investigator who always placed the needs of her clients first.
Post a Comment
<< Home